MODERN ARCHIVISTS

The Vault

What a Broken Garbage Disposal Taught Us About Hiring a Witness

filed under:

Weddings

Hi, I'm Alexandra Day, a photographer, author and creative director based in the United States. So glad you're here.

Let me set the scene.

It’s a Tuesday. Matthew is on his third YouTube tutorial of the evening, the kind with a thumbnail of a very confident man holding an Allen wrench like it’s a weapon. I am standing behind him holding a flashlight I have been asked to hold “just a little to the left” for eleven minutes. Our kitchen sink has not drained in two days. There is a smell. We do not talk about the smell.

This is the part of the story where I tell you we tried everything, and I mean everything.

We ran hot water down there like we were trying to apologize to it. We poured in enough Drano to strip paint off a boat. We tried the Allen wrench trick from the tutorial. We tried unplugging it and plugging it back in like it was a router. We tried, at one particularly low point, just staring at it, as if eye contact might shame it into working. We tried the trick that had worked before — closing the cabinet, leaving the kitchen, giving it space to forgive us for whatever we’d put down there — but this time it didn’t take. We came back an hour later, cautiously, like we were checking on a toddler who’d gone quiet, and nothing had changed.

Here is what nobody tells you about the DIY route: it is not that it doesn’t work at all. It’s that it works just enough. The water drains for a day. You start to believe you’ve fixed it. You tell people at dinner, “oh yeah, we actually got it running again,” with the confidence of two people who watched forty-five minutes of a stranger’s garage footage and now consider themselves qualified. And then Thursday comes, and the smell comes back, and you are once again on your knees with a flashlight, humbled.

We finally called someone. A real professional that cost us real money. The kind of money we were trying to avoid spending. A person with a truck and a uniform and a tool that did not come from our garage. He was in and out in forty minutes. Forty minutes, for what we had spent four days — and, if we’re counting the tantrums before this one, honestly months — trying to solve ourselves.

Here’s what he told us, standing in our kitchen like a man delivering news we should’ve heard years ago: the pipes weren’t fitted properly. Not broken, exactly. Just old. Our house is sixty years old, and the plumbing underneath our sink was arranged the way plumbing was arranged sixty years ago — a layout that made sense once, in a kitchen that no longer exists, running water for a family that used it differently than we do. It wasn’t a clog. It was a congested traffic zone, he called it, a bottleneck built into the very structure of the thing, and no amount of hot water or willpower or well-intentioned walking away was ever going to fix a design problem. We would never have known that. We certainly wouldn’t have known how to re-pipe it so it flowed the way it was supposed to. We didn’t even know that was a thing that could be wrong.

I don’t think this was really a story about a garbage disposal.

I think about this a lot when I talk to couples who are trying to decide whether they need an experienced wedding photographer, or whether someone still finding their footing will do. I understand the instinct. I do. It looks simple from the outside. It looks like something a beginner could probably figure out, with enough tutorials, enough good intentions, enough hot water thrown at the problem.

And let me say this clearly, because I mean it: every photographer alive started as a beginner. Matthew did. I did. Learning is not the enemy here, and I have deep respect for anyone willing to pick up a camera and figure out how light works from scratch. But there is a right way to learn on a wedding day, and it is not as the lead, carrying an entire couple’s only record of the day on shoulders that have never carried that weight before. It’s as a second shooter — beside a mentor who already knows where to stand, who has already made the mistakes so that those same mistakes aren’t made on your wedding day. That is how a beginner grows into someone trustworthy. Not by practicing on your one and only day, and hoping your album doesn’t pay the tuition for their education.

And sometimes the DIY version does drain for a day. The photos come back and they’re fine. They’re fine. But a wedding day only happens once, and there is no calling someone back out on Thursday to redo the first look, no forty-minute fix for a memory that didn’t get preserved the way it deserved to be. You don’t get a second truck.

This is the whole reason we exist, if I’m honest. Not to take pictures — anyone with a camera can take pictures. We are there because we know where to stand when your father sees you for the first time. We know how the light moves through a room over the course of an evening, and where to be when it does. We know that the story is never really in the big, planned moments — it’s in the four seconds before them. That is not a YouTube tutorial. That is not something you can shame into working by staring at it hard enough.

Presence is the product. It always has been. It’s why we take a limited number of weddings a year — because this work asks for the kind of attention you can’t fake your way into, the kind our God calls us to bring to anything worth doing well.

Here is the part I really want you to hear.

The cheapest option is never actually the cheapest option. Not on your kitchen sink, and certainly not on the one day you will spend the rest of your life looking back on. When you hire the vendor who was easiest on the budget, you don’t just save a little money — you inherit a job. Suddenly you’re the one double-checking the shot list, following up to make sure they know your grandmother is in a wheelchair and needs a clear path, hovering near the timeline like a stage manager instead of standing in it like a bride. You become the project manager of your own wedding day. That is not a role I want for you. That is not a role you will remember fondly.

What a good investment actually buys you is not just better photographs. It buys you absence — the good kind. The absence of worry. The absence of micromanaging a stranger you’re not sure you can trust yet. It removes you entirely from the role of frazzled robot, reciting directions like it’s the first day of puppy training class.

What you want instead is someone tried and true. Someone dedicated — the kind of dedicated that shows up in the small things, the follow-through, the way they learn your family before they ever pick up a camera. Someone who lives and breathes this craft, who takes the time to understand what’s unique to you, so that on the day itself, you don’t have to explain yourself to anyone. You just get to be there. Fully. Undivided. Present in your own life for the hours that will define how you remember it.

So — call the professional. For the disposal. For the wedding. Let someone else hold the flashlight this time.

Your favorite reluctant plumber’s assistant, — Alexandra

Hi, I'm Alexandra Day, a photographer, author and creative director based in the United States. So glad you're here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

The LATEST

Welcome to The Archives. Not a curated feed or webpage filled with photos and packages. These are the real stories and people behind Modern Archivists.

Behind the Brand

Alexandra +Matthew

Matthew sees in frames. Alexandra thinks in timelines. Together they have built a studio where the creative and the experiential are equally obsessed over — because a breathtaking gallery delivered through a forgettable experience is not the standard here.  Different gifts. One vision. And a level of investment in your day that most teams simply cannot replicate.

READ MORE →

FAVORITE pOSTS & RESOURCES

The portrait Shoot Style guide

TIPS FOR THE BEST GOLDEN HOUR PHOTOS

a few of our curated

FAVORITES

BEST ELOPEMENT LOCALES

tennic-chic elopEment inspo

SPRING BOOK LIST

AMALFI ON FILM

Free Download

The IDEAL TIMELINE GUIDE

Heirloom schlitz synth, humblebrag scenester tumblr plaid narwhal offal tofu authentic hell of umami. Williamsburg sartorial put a bird on it craft beer.